Friday, 25 January 2013

Exploring The Real Reasons Behind The Driver Shortage

This post appears in the February 2012 edition of the Truck News



I had breakfast with a buddy a short while ago and he's a guy that is usually upbeat and looking at the sunny side of things. So as we were talking about the state of affairs out here on the road I was a little taken aback when he said that it just wasn't any fun out here anymore. I've heard similar statements from many drivers over the past couple of years and I usually just put it off to a venting of frustrations when a couple of drivers get together. But as I thought about our conversation afterward I realized that these types of comments are coming from drivers that I don't usually associate with a lot of bitching about nothing. They are coming from seasoned drivers with lots of experience. My overall impression is that folks are simply tired out and run down. So naturally I wondered if the driver shortage that gets so much ink in the trucking media these days is showing up in the way of added stress and fatigue to drivers. Lots has been written about attracting new blood to the industry but not so much about what the effects are on the existing pool of drivers that are picking up the slack.

Think of our present drivers as a group of elite athletes. Okay, I know this may be a stretch but bear with me. Your watching game 7 of a Stanley Cup final. More than half of the players on both teams are seasoned veterans well past the halfway point in their careers. But the chips are down and they all have their game on, playing with an intensity of guys half their age. You know when the game is done that there is no way these players could play every game in a long season with that same level of effort. But when called on they get the job done.

So now back to our present team of drivers. More than half of us are well past the halfway point in our careers and many of us are feeling the effects. Those effects are reflected in the general state of our health. For the past few years we've been called on to pick up the slack and put in the extra effort. Most of us have had our game on and risen to the call. But unlike a group of athletes that 'peak' for a playoff series we just keep going with no end in sight. Unlike the hockey players we don't have an off season to recover or someone to substitute for us for a game or two during the regular season.

We have also been handicapped in a number of ways. The referees in our industry are calling a tight game. Despite the greater demands on our time we face harsher penalties if we break the rules. Up until a few years ago our game was open ended allowing us the flexibility to stretch out our duties and rest in between. Now we have to complete many of our jobs within a tighter window of time or face a penalty. Our income has not kept up with inflation over the past couple of decades so the once above average income we enjoyed has shrunk to an average middle class income at best. No longer does a driver have the luxury to take time whenever he or she wants it to recharge with family and friends. Many of us are working paycheck to paycheck, living on the road, and just going home to visit.

In my opinion there is not a driver shortage at all. Drivers now receive an average income for an above average investment of time in an industry where bureaucracy has run amuck. As a result the freedom of the open road does not hold the same attraction to potential drivers and is quickly losing its luster within the existing pool of drivers.

Shrinking incomes and longer work hours are not unique to the trucking industry. It's a story repeated across a broad swath of our society. The message we are getting on the front lines is one of austerity. We are told to do more with less in order for companies to remain competetive and create more jobs. At the same time we receive constant messaging to consume more which fuels economic growth. Earn less but spend more? Maybe I'm getting the wrong message but I don't think so.

The good news is that many of us work for smaller family owned businesses that don't operate by the same rules of austerity as the large public corporations. But they don't have the deep pockets that their large competitors do so they can't keep their drivers happy by throwing money at them. They need to find creative ways to keep and attract drivers. As drivers we can help them do that and in doing so help ourselves. I'll come back to this in future columns.

Coping With Reporting Technology


This post appears in the January 2012 edition of the Truck News

When I switched to electronic logs a couple of years ago I was very keen about the potential going electronic had for making my life easier. The fact I don't have to spend any time filling out log pages and performing manual recaps is reason enough for me to never turn back. But my belief that an electronic system would make managing my time easier and less stressful has proven to be somewhat of a pipe dream. In many regards an electronic log is an unrelenting task master that does not allow you any flexibility. You have to complete your daily tasks within a given time frame regardless of the curves that are routinely thrown your way over the course of any given day. As drivers we see lots of junk thrown our way. Weather, dock delays, equipment failure, border crossings, unforeseen traffic problems, etc. etc.

So rather than relieving stress as I had originally believed it would, electronic logs have added a considerable amount of stress to my day and have become a means of measuring my performance. In fact the trend seems to be towards measuring driver performance through critical incidence reporting via a trucks on board software. Reports are generated automatically and emailed to a drivers safety manager. And it doesn't stop there. Programs have also been developed and rolled out to notify a drivers manager when a driver is showing signs of fatigue so that preventative action can be taken.

I'm not even going to attempt to dispute the fact that all of this information can be beneficial for a carrier in a number of ways. It can reduce costs, assure compliance with legislation, reduce accidents, create learning opportunities for drivers, improve overall safety, and so on. But if these programs are so wonderful why am I left feeling stressed and tired at the end of the day? Shouldn't all of this stuff be helping to make my experience on the road happier, healthier, and give me more time for myself and my family? Where is the efficiency in this system?

The fact is that all of these software solutions designed to provide greater economic efficiencies and a higher degree of safety are often not designed with the driver in mind. At least that's my assumption as an end user of this technology. I think that drivers want the same thing as the carriers and enforcement agency’s when it comes to safety and efficiency, but the parties are miles apart when it comes to methodology and implementation of these tools. Why? Because drivers often view these in cab systems that monitor their performance as big brother watching over you. The nature of the system reporting is a form of constant negative re-enforcement to a driver. It only tells you when you are doing something wrong no matter the gravity, circumstance, or context of the situation at hand. That's irritating, frustrating, and demoralizing. At least that's my personal feeling. There is no accounting for the hundreds, perhaps thousands, of things I do right in the course of my day.

What if an incident reporting system was developed that turned the whole thing around? What if reports were to be generated for all the positive actions that occur in the course of a professional drivers day? There would be so many emails generated to our respective safety departments that we may very well crash the company server. Man, it would be great to get immediate positive feedback in recognition of a job well done.

How about a resolution for 2012 that only allows satellite messages sent to the truck to be positive in nature. In addition to that for every critical incident report generated by on board performance monitoring software that is brought to the drivers attention by a carriers safety department, they have to also discuss two positive incidents generated by the driver on the same day. I think that would go a long way to relieving driver stress, improve driver morale, and improve overall driver health in 2012. Imagine the effects on productivity!

There is no doubt in my mind that you can't go back to the way things were in this life. Life is impermanent in nature and changes continuously. That means that the situation at hand in the present moment is bound to change tomorrow or the next day or the day after that. I also believe we can influence that change. We have monitoring systems that feed drivers with a stream of data highlighting their shortcomings and expect improvement. But if that information isn't framed within a compassionate intention to benefit the driver it will erode performance not enhance it.

I know safety managers have an especially tough job these days. If they want to build trust with their drivers I believe they need to find creative ways to soften this reporting technology, embody it with a little humanity, and frequently reassure their drivers that as long as they are sitting in the wheelhouse the drivers decision is final.

Cheers, and happy new year to all.


Time Is Of The Essence


This post appears in the November 2011 edition of the Truck News

One of the things I enjoy most about trucking is the time you have to spend with yourself. That probably sounds a little strange but that's what I equate with the freedom of the open road. You're free from interference, restrictions, and external authority. You're independent. Many drivers would say that our freedom and independence is under threat from unnecessary rules and interference from government and special interest groups. I wouldn't say all rules are unnecessary and I'm not big on conspiracy theories but I do think our independence has been compromised because of the universal controls placed on our time. By imposing change through legislation rather than effecting change through ongoing training and professional development how can drivers not feel their independence is under threat? Each individual driver needs the flexibility to plan their own time in order to meet all the demands placed on them while obtaining the required rest to operate safely. Drivers wonder amongst themselves why this basic tenet of safety is so difficult to comprehend outside the driver pool.

So as I've been writing about the trucking lifestyle and driver health issues over the course of the past several months I've been searching for the common denominator we all share. What is the key issue that effects the well being of all drivers? It's been in front of me all along and that is the issue of 'time' itself. Within the industry time has morphed into an economic factor over the past few decades to be managed by companies as a means of controlling costs. In fact time is the lifestyle factor that effects every aspect of a drivers health and well being. Time is now the primary stressor that impedes a drivers performance rather than the enabler it should be. Look at just a few examples and it becomes obvious how time impacts driver lifestyle at every turn.

First, look at the issue of income. In the past drivers have enjoyed an above average income for the work they have performed. This has allowed a driver to step away from the truck for a period of time when the demands of family, fatigue, and the simple need for leisure time require it. But that is now a thing of the past. Income has not kept pace with the cost of living and now drivers work continuously to maintain the standard of living they have enjoyed in the past. Drivers now are required to work at their performance peak continuously. The result is a constant state of burnout and low morale. It has become increasingly more difficult to look after ourselves, to put ourselves before the demands of the job.

Second, look at the HoS (Hours of Service) issue and the related issue of EOBR's. (Electronic on Board Recorders) Look at all the research that has been performed in the past and continues today in relation to sleep science and the effects of fatigue on drivers. Drivers get it. This information goes to the core of coping with and managing fatigue as drivers go about their daily duties. But was this data presented as an enabler to improving the lifestyle of the individual driver? No. It has been wrapped in a legislative blanket that stymies performance and in many instances leads to situations that incite fatigue and push drivers beyond their comfort zone.

Third, look at the issue of driver training and retention. In the past independent truckers made up the majority of the driver pool and the development and mentoring of drivers was a part of daily life on the road. Now we have safety departments with a focus on compliance over training. The time that is needed to invest in driver training and mentoring has been cut in the name of cost reduction and the trucking industry has built itself a precarious house of cards. With an aging demographic and a lackluster attitude towards developing professional drivers over Mctruckers it is no wonder that many industry managers and owners now share a genuine concern that the industry is facing a perfect storm when it comes to this issue.

What is the bottom line here? Our industry is all about service. Corporate profitability is dependent on a drivers performance and well being. Drivers need to operate in an environment that feeds their sense of independence and freedom in order to enjoy their work and in order to attract new blood into the industry. Cutting into a drivers time may have showed short term gains on the bottom line of many corporate operating statements but we are now left with a lingering long term malaise as a result. It's time for the industry to reinvest in it's driver pool by providing adequate rest time, taking a fresh approach to fatigue management, and providing ongoing and professional driver training.



Technology Doesn't Have To Spell The End Of Our Indepencence

This post appears in the October 2011 issue of the Truck News


Over the past 3 or 4 months I've been focusing a lot on the health challenges we face as we go about our business of trucking. It's one thing to eat right and get some exercise but it is the stresses we face each day and the fatigue we experience from our long work days and time away from home that effects our health more than anything else. These issues we can't solve on our own.

It's interesting that Ontario is recognized as one of the leaders in commercial vehicle safety enforcement while at the same time they lag far behind other jurisdictions in regard to providing adequate parking and rest areas for commercial drivers. I stopped at a modern rest area on the I90/94 corridor just west of Madison, Wisconsin last week and counted 68 truck parking spots. Add to that the curbside parking behind the parked trucks and you would get no less than 100 trucks into this rest area. All of the midwest states I travel through provide modern rest areas along the interstate highways. We can learn much from our neighbors to the south in this regard.

We need modern rest areas located 2 to 3 hours apart across the length of the Trans Canada highway such as you find between Montreal and the New Brunswick border. Kudos to the province of Quebec for providing rest areas with heated restrooms, running water, and truck parking.

This is an issue of health, safety, and security. The trucking lobby could do a much better job of using this issue to gain some leverage with the public. I wouldn't call the trucking industry a leader when it comes to issues of health and safety in the workplace. The transportation network is our workplace. Unlike industry specific issues such as speed limiters, hours of service regulations, and electronic on board recorders that the public has difficulty getting their heads around, highway rest areas is an issue we share with the motoring public. After all, everybody needs to use a restroom at some point.

There is also an impact on our smaller communities that bear the brunt of all the heavy traffic that passes by their communities on a daily basis. Recently Linda Nowicki, the mayor of Wawa, reached out to the Ontario Trucking Association asking that a campaign be commenced to address the issue of “truck bombs”, better known as bottles of urine, tossed out on the sides of the road in and around their community by transport drivers. A lack of rest areas does not make this behavior acceptable but it has contributed to it. This behavior by drivers is becoming commonplace across the country.

Then there is the hours of service issue. Compliance with hours of service legislation (HoS) is a major stressor in the lives of drivers. The introduction of electronic on board recorders (EOBR's) has further compounded that stress. I think it's fair to say that many drivers see this as a control issue. After all most of us were attracted to this industry because we did not want to punch a time clock every day. It's the desire of every professional driver to operate safely and responsibly but at the same time we want to maintain that feeling of freedom that comes with the open road. I think many drivers feel that freedom has been taken away from them, or is in the process of being taken away from them, in the guise of big brother in the cab. That's unfortunate because this technology has the capability of opening up doors for drivers not closing them.

I choose to look at the HoS rules and EOBR's as enablers not limiters. I'm lucky in the sense that I work for a carrier that empowers me to make many of my own decisions in regard to my time. My relationship with our operations people is as part of a team not a boss/employee relationship. I recognize that that is not the normal mode of operation for many drivers out there. That's what has to change. That's where the feeling of freedom comes from.

Perhaps the biggest problem is that the demographic within management is the same as that of the drivers. A large majority are in the 50 plus range and still trying to adapt new technology to the way things have always been done rather than dealing with the present moment and looking to the future. It's time for carriers and enforcement to step back and take a new look at the way we do things. We don't have to give up our passion for this work, the freedom of the road, the liberation of the open road that we enjoy. This technology should support that and improve it. After all we have a real problem right now attracting new people to the industry. We are not going to attract them by beating them over the head with new technology. We need to use it to entice them into an exciting career.

As Professional Drivers, We Need To Look After Ourselves First

This post appears in the September 2011 issue of the Truck News


I wanted to continue writing about driver health issues this month but was beginning to feel like I was flogging a dead horse. That isn't the case according to the results of a recent Health & Wellness Survey of Transport Truck Drivers conducted by the Department of Family Medicine at McMaster University & City of Hamilton, Public Health Services. According to the survey 33.1% of drivers say they are willing to participate in Workplace Wellness programs on their own time. So a large number of drivers recognize that the trucking lifestyle has a negative impact on their health and they would like to do something about it. As drivers we know that there is a huge divide between our intention to live a healthier lifestyle and our ability to carry through with that intention. I think most drivers would agree that time is the limiting factor we all share. It's fair to say we simply don't have enough of it. This point was driven home to me over the course of the past week.

I left southwestern Ontario last Saturday morning and headed up to Winnipeg/Brandon where I peddled freight around all day Monday. Tuesday I reloaded down around Fargo and was back at my home terminal early on Thursday. Over 3,000 miles, 12 picks and drops along with the border crossings makes for a busy week. My EOBR showed me either on duty or driving for a total of 67 hours. Not any different than the 300,000 other Canadian truck drivers doing the same thing as me. We do that week in and week out right? You bet we do.

Waiting at the yard for me was my car sitting on one very flat tire. Okay, I kept ignoring that 'need new tires' item on my to do list and now I was forced into crisis management mode. I also had a 'needs brake service', and 'needs emissions test for permit renewal' on that same list. At home I had another list with items such as: 'trim cedar hedge around backyard', 'fix slow leak (for now) on upstairs toilet', and let's not forget 'meet deadline (today) for Truck News column'. There are many other items I could add to these lists and I know that every driver out there has lists just like them. Where does 'family time' and 'leisure time' fit on those lists? What about 'exercise time'? It's pretty easy to see why we call truck driving a lifestyle and not a job or a career. When you drive a truck it becomes a part of who you are not just what you do for a living.

Something else happened last night that put all of that on the back burner. My daughter went into labor with our first grandchild four weeks ahead of schedule. SURPRISE!! Thankfully everything went smoothly, Mom and baby are fine, healthy, and happy. Standing next to my daughter this morning with Nate, my grandson, in my arms and my wife by my side, I recognized that making the time to live a healthy lifestyle was about my whole life not just about my physical well being.

When was the last time anyone within our industry took the time to coach you on the benefits of including your own time into your trip planning? Making sure that you had time to sleep, to eat, to relax etc. Why don't we plan for ourselves and in doing so still accommodate the needs of our shippers, receivers, carriers, and enforcement agencies and they for us (drivers) in their planning?

I've become involved with a Transportation Industry Health Promotion Research and Policy Planning Group which was created by the two organizations I mentioned at the top of the column that are responsible for the driver survey that kicked things off. I'm impressed with the passion, sincerity, and genuine concern the members of the group have for improving the quality of life for transport drivers. The thing that bothers me is that of the 37 or so members that attended the first session I was the only driver. Drivers are a very diverse group and greater representation and participation is needed in order for the professionals and academics that drive the group to make the best use of their skills to help us improve the quality of our lives out here on the road.

Too often we bitch and complain after the fact about plans and policy’s that are put into place for our benefit. Think of the hours of service rules and policy regarding EOBR's. The intense research done prior to the implementation of these policies was intended to benefit us not limit us or control us. As drivers we too often sit back and allow things to happen without participating in the process. I know it takes time, of which we already have little to spare, but if we don't actively participate in the process we are giving up the independence that attracted most of us to this profession in the first place.  

Monday, 23 July 2012

Happy Monday

I decided I had better leave southern Ontario last Friday night in order to cope with all the weekend warriors heading up into cottage country. Problem was my load was not ready until it was too late to leave so I ended up joining the fray on highway 400 anyway come Saturday morning. That resulted in lost time that added up to me running five minutes over my drive time getting in to Winnipeg on Sunday night. Kiss that months safety bonus goodbye.
So I've only got five drops but one has been decked and the receiver has no loading dock so I'll have to go somewhere and undeck it before making delivery. Another one requires a delivery appointment that wasn't arranged. They also only receive until noon. (Yes, that's right, NOON! !) I'm also supposed to switch wagons with a driver that has Brandon, Winkler, and Winnipeg deliveries to do first leaving me with Duluth and Green Bay to do tomorrow. Umm, yea, sure.
So after making my calls early this morning to deal with all that I did what any normal person would do. Strapped on my running shoes, filled my water bottles and went out for a run for a couple of hours.
Like a slow running stream drivers have to flow around obstacles not try and climb over them. We wear them down over time.  Bwahahaha.
Until all the players in this industry learn to work together recruiting professional drivers will continue to be a hot issue. We're growing weary of the nonsense.

Sunday, 10 June 2012

Hot & Hazy

It's hot and hazy up here in Hearst. The Weather Network is telling me that it feels like 32°C with the humidity. Feels like a hell of a lot more than that sitting in my black truck. The wind has picked up as the temperature has increased. Swirling eddies of dust blow across the now empty parking lot here at the Husky truck stop. As you can see there is not much of a view. I'm waiting for my switch, unable to sleep anymore in the light of day. I will have fulfilled my time off requirements for the day by the time my switch arrives. In theory that makes me well rested for the 11.5 hour drive back to the south. Of course I know better. The last 4 hours will test my stamina.

I've been giving some thought to the panel discussion on driver incentive programs that I will be participating in this coming Tuesday. I attempt to participate regularly in the monthly meeting of the Central Ontario Chapter of the Fleet Safety Council but it's difficult as a driver to make the time available. Available time is at the core of my position regarding incentive programs.

Time to work, time to sleep, time to play, time to eat, time to prepare food, time to exercise, time to plan, time to put your feet up and relax, time to participate in community, time to be a husband, a dad, a grandad, a friend, a neighbor.

Time is in short supply when a truck driver needs it the most yet is abundant when a driver is least able to make the best use of it. That's the position I find myself in this afternoon. It's not the first time and I'm sure it won't be the last.

I'm kicking myself because I volunteered to do this switch. I'd had a long week last week running home doing multiple pick ups in South Dakota and Iowa, but there was plenty of freight to move and too much time off makes for a light pay packet. That was my reasoning. Seemed pretty rational at the time. But now that I find myself in the position of feeling tired before I start and face the prospect of working through the night and having to sleep when I get home in the daytime, well that totally screws up my time off and plans with family.

So this is a core issue the trucking industry needs to address somehow. Taking the hours of wasted time on the road and making them available for a drivers personal use outside of his or her workplace (truck). Simple? Not at all. But necessary.

We need profit sharing based programs that promote efficiency and communication across the whole industry to start tackling this issue. As long as drivers are left sitting on evenings and weekends absorbing the inefficiencies of the Monday to Friday workweek while still meeting delivery expectations at a personal cost to themselves, the driver shortage will continue to deepen until it reaches crisis proportions. It seems like we're almost there.

I love to drive and love the sense of freedom and independence this work brings to me. But not at any cost.