Showing posts with label Incentive Programs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Incentive Programs. Show all posts

Sunday, 1 January 2017

Why Drivers Need to Keep an Open Mind

This post appeared in the September 2016 edition of Truck News

For some, social media is like chocolate cake, you just can't get enough. Algorithms tailor our social media news feeds to surround us with the sweet taste of our own ideas and beliefs. But that sweet fatty diet is poison to us in the long run. Our bodies need variation in our diet with a focus on healthy foods to stay healthy over the long term. We need to apply those same rules to our media diet. By consuming only the sweet memes and the tasty click-bait, we poison our mental environment that in turn affects our ability to think clearly and objectively about the issues important to us.

The debate raging around electronic logging devices, or ELD’s, is a case in point. On one side we have the opinion that ELD’s are an invasion of our personal rights and freedoms so should not be mandated. On the other side the argument is made that road safety hinges on ALL trucks having these devices in place thereby leveling the playing field by making sure that everyone is playing by the same rules. There does not seem to be any middle ground in this debate yet most drivers fall between these two extremes. All drivers must keep a daily log of their activity, there is no debate over that point. Large corporate carriers insist on increasing their technological presence in the cab using invasive technology and independent drivers insist on maintaining paper logs that can easily skirt the letter of the law. Both sides pay lip service to the core issues of public safety and driver safety by building an echo chamber to their cause through social media.

This is not an issue that has only two sides. In today's connected world drivers need the data that technology provides to protect their rights and their safety more now than ever. They do not need legislation to ram it down their throats. Drivers need education and training. The legislation should be focused on protecting a driver’s privacy not solely on a corporation’s right to impose practices that benefit their bottom line. There is a middle road and it is about ethics and morality not about the law.
For six years I have been using an ELD. It has brought benefits to both the company I work for and for myself. It has not hampered my ability to earn a living. I run just under 3,000 miles every week (5 days) in both Canada and the USA. The company has been able to use the data it captures to provide an incentive program that has not only increased profits for the company but has provided additional income for the majority of its drivers. We are one of the few companies our size that maintains the highest CVOR rating available for the past 3 years running and has also been voted one of the top ten companies to work for in Canada by its drivers, also for 3 years running. Is this because an ELD law has been mandated? Of course not. It is because of the honesty and integrity the owners bring to the table. Drivers are partners in the business not tools of the trade. Technology has been and continues to be incorporated in a way that is beneficial to all. Are there growing pains? Yes. Could these gains have been made operating in a digital world with paper logs and no technology to capture the data that guides that ethical decision making? Of course not.

I agree wholeheartedly that as drivers we need to band together to speak out against the imposition of technology that focuses solely on the financial return to the corporate investor at the expense of the health and well-being of the individual driver. I do not support legislating ELD’s across the board. The small independent trucker has increasing access to technology to compete in today’s market just as any other small business person does. Government should be making sure that that access remains open and is expanded to entrepreneurs by not imposing costly fixes that benefit only the large corporations. If independent truckers want to continue to operate with analog systems like paper logs in the digital world that we live in then let them. In another decade this business practice will dry up as so many manual systems have. They will not be cost effective and will not provide the information needed to compete in the modern marketplace.


We need an educated well informed driver pool to make sure this industry remains healthy not just for the driver but for the companies we work for and contract our services to. Drivers need to diversify their sources of information and refrain from making decisions based on internet memes, sound bites, and headlines. Open your mind, research opposing opinions, engage in friendly debate and ask why, why, why. The health of our industry depends on it.

Friday, 25 January 2013

Sometimes A Good Incentive Program Isn't About Money

This post appears in the August edition of the Truck News

Truck NewsI wrote last months column prior to participating in a panel discussion on the topic of driver incentive programs. This months column is the post discussion installment.

The event took place at the June 2012 meeting of the Central Ontario Chapter of the Fleet Safety Council. Driver incentives were presented from the perspective of Owner, General Manager, Safety Manager, Dispatcher, Driver, Fixed Operation Staff (dock, warehouse, shop, administration), and Insurance.

The diversity of ideas that break out when you have a broad cross section of people from across the industry coming together to discuss a topic common to all is fascinating. But what is also apparent is that drivers are under represented in these discussions. I find that at these events I am often the only active driver in the room. That is not a criticism or complaint but an observation that in our industry the people in the best position to offer feedback leading to improved efficiency & productivity are most often not in the room to air their concerns and ideas. We live in a time that has been coined as the 'golden age of communication'. We definitely need to find a way to move the discussions that take place amongst drivers on the CB and in the truck stops to the offices and board rooms of the trucking industry.

The second thing that was apparent to me was the age of the participants. Most of the meetings I attend are dominated by the boomer demographic. It's not just the driver pool that is aging. Fresh faces bring fresh ideas. The youth that carriers are attempting to attract to the industry have developed a different set of social skills from the boomers that currently dominate the trucking industry. Have you noticed how we (boomers) tend to take new technologies like social media and twist it into a form we are comfortable with? The youth of today live their lives openly on the internet with few inhibitions or limits and adapt quickly to the rapid changes that are taking place around them both technically and socially. We boomers with our depth of experience usually feel we have much to offer but often forget we have much to learn. The best drivers, the ones that have decades of incident free driving, will often say that the day you think you have seen it all is the day that you should hang up the keys. We need to apply that principle to the industry as a whole.

Am I starting to sound a little negative? Just a bunch of non driving old fogies sitting around making decisions for people doing a job that they are out of touch with? Sorry about that but the fact is that as I cruise across the highways and byways listening to other drivers that is not an uncommon complaint. But it is a complaint that is unfounded in many ways and stems from the communication divide that has developed over the years between drivers and support staff. Owners and managers truly have the best interests of drivers as their prime concern, those that don't do not remain in business for long, especially in our current economy. That is the third thing that stood out for me in our panel discussion, the quality of incentive programs that are in place out there and the genuine concern for the well being of drivers.

What do some of those incentive programs look like? Programs are as diverse as the companies that make up the trucking industry. Many still focus on safety & fuel bonuses as prime motivators. What some people may find surprising is that the most powerful programs we discussed were not monetary based but focused on wellness (driver health) and recognition. Recognition was identified as the key in every successful incentive program. We all want to be complimented and rewarded for a job well done no matter what our position is. So there is definitely no rocket science behind incentive programs. It's simply about treating people well and recognizing them for their accomplishments and those programs work far better when the primary players participate in the process from start to finish.

Some of the fastest growing programs right now are the health and wellness programs. This is a reflection of our aging demographic. There have been weight loss challenges between different companies to motivate healthier lifestyles. Some companies have brought in third party players to administer healthy lifestyle living programs that will aid drivers in developing new habits for eating, exercising and addressing the psychological issues we face in dealing with these lifestyle issues.

All in all it was heartening to see the energy and time that is spent by owners and managers to care for their driver pool.


Why Profit Sharing May Be The Ultimate Incentive Program For Owners & Drivers

This post appears in the July 2012 edition of the Truck News


A few months ago I was asked by the central Ontario chapter of the Fleet Safety Council if I would like to participate in an upcoming panel discussion about driver incentive programs. I accepted, always eager to offer my two cents from a drivers perspective. As thoughts about this topic percolated in my mind over the months I've had quite some difficulty coming to any type of concrete opinion on what a driver incentive program should look like. The best place to start is to gain some understanding of what is meant when we talk about driver incentive.

If you look up a dictionary definition of the word 'incentive' you will get back something to this effect:a reward offered for increased productivity. Increasing productivity is usually associated with an increase in the volume of work performed (usually accomplished by investing more time in the job), performing the same volume of work at a lower cost (fuel savings, accident free), or meeting a higher standard of performance(improving CSA scores or Carrier Rating). The reward to the driver is most often a financial one.

What I find really interesting is that an increase in productivity requires an investment of additional time by the driver. Yet in recent years changes to Hours of Service legislation (HoS) and use of Electronic On Board Recorders (EOBR's) has tightened control over a drivers time. At the same time most of us are still payed by the mile and by the drop. This system was put into place to encourage productivity also. Run more miles, do more drops, and you get payed more. But that system was put into place when HoS rules were loosely enforced or non existent. So what we have now is the operations side of our business still paying drivers by the mile encouraging them to work as quickly as possible in the name of productivity and incentive programs that are designed to slow us down and work more efficiently & safely. This presents somewhat of a paradox for drivers. It's no wonder that drivers often express the feeling that they are stuck between a rock and a hard place because the expectations of the operations side of the business and the safety & compliance side of the business clash. So as a driver are you going to place your efforts on the operations side that pays you 40 cents a mile every week or on the safety and compliance side that presents you with the potential to earn up to another 2-6 cents per mile each quarter, if you meet the criteria? It's no surprise that many drivers feel it's just not worth the effort. Maybe we're well past the time of looking for a new means of paying drivers for their efforts as well as developing new incentive programs.

What if I'm more interested in earning the same money but doing it in less time allowing me more personal time? Is there an incentive program out there that will do that? Perhaps. Some companies are implementing profit sharing programs. These programs present the opportunity to involve all employees, not just drivers, in the incentive program. They have the potential to foster greater teamwork and break down communication barriers between departments. A profit sharing program fixes the cost of an incentive program as a percentage of net profit for the company so it aids in financial forecasting and planning. But it requires diligent and consistent messaging from all levels of management to front line employees. Everyone has to be working towards the same goal. I've learned over the years as a driver that communication with front line employees is not a strength that this industry possesses. That's not a criticism it's a recognition of the difficulty we all face in developing relationships with one another when we rarely see one another. That lack of social interaction is difficult to overcome in an industry that keeps managers and workers thousands of kilometers apart most of the time. A successful profit sharing program depends on constant interaction between all employees if there is to be a payoff. That payoff has the potential to be no less than a satisfactory set of HoS rules that recognizes the need for flexibility in a drivers daily routine and an end to downloading inefficiencies such as dock delays to the driver.

As an aging driver I find that I am increasingly frustrated by the lack of time I can spend with my family and invest in my own personal well being. Issues of driver health and wellness are coming to the forefront and facing up to this reality is what incentive programs also have to address. It does not seem reasonable to me to ask an aging driver pool to invest even more time in the name of productivity while expecting them to take more time to care for themselves. You just can't have it both ways.

What's Got Me Down? It's a Matter Of Time

This post appears in the March 2012 edition of the Truck News


Last month I closed off my column saying that carriers need to find new and creative ways of attracting and holding on to drivers. Shortly after submitting that column I was asked if I had an interest in participating in a panel discussion regarding driver incentive programs. So I thought I would wade into that topic here while it was still fresh in my mind. It also comes at a time when the Truckload Carriers Association (www.truckload.org) will be recognizing the top fleets to drive for (www.bestfleetstodrivefor.com) as nominated by company drivers and owner operators. Several Canadian companies are in the top 20 group and you can read about them on the web sites above as well as here in the Truck News.

I work for a company that stands shoulder to shoulder with the best in the Canadian trucking industry in the way they care for their drivers and the core values that embody their operations. In fact a new incentive program was put in place January 1 of this year for our drivers. Despite that, I have still been experiencing a feelings of discontent and anxiety over the past several months. Colleagues have commented on the degradation of my outlook of late. A comment from a regular reader stated that although they had enjoyed a recent column they felt it was in a negative tone compared to my usual style. Another comment came from within my dispatch office regarding my negative reaction to a situation that had arisen and the feeling that it was out of character for me to react as I did. Can I identify a single factor within my trucking lifestyle that leads to the daily stress I have been experiencing? Could a driver incentive program reduce my daily stress at the same time as providing me with a financial reward and reduce costs/improve profits for my employer?

Identifying the stressor in my daily life on the road is not difficult. It is time. Time is something I always take for granted but it comes up for me over and over again as the leading cause of tension in my life. The birth of my grandson last year lead to a feeling of deep desire to spend more time with my family. The recognition of my need to obtain regular exercise and rest requires a time commitment each and everyday. My time is my most valuable commodity. When my time is being wasted or taken for granted my immediate emotional response is usually one of anger and frustration leading to the feelings of stress and anxiety. Then the endless hours of driving play their part as my mind locks on to those feelings and replays them over and over building on them and strengthening them. The result is an internal conflict over the time I have available to accommodate my personal life and personal aspirations versus the huge block of time required to fulfill my professional obligations as a driver. I often feel a lack of control over my time because so much of my day is dependent on the actions of others. Specifically operations and dispatch along with the shippers and receivers I deal with.

So I was excited to see that profit sharing programs are on the leading edge of new incentive programs being developed by carriers. Why? Because they have the potential to drive a greater level of cooperation and communication within trucking companies. Too often productivity increases have been equated with a driver doing more within a given time or becoming more efficient with the use of their time. Little attention seems to be payed to the fact that drivers already invest well over 3000 hours a year in their jobs compared to the 2000 hours most full time workers put in. That's before you even consider that a driver also lives in his or her workplace. An incentive program needs to reward every employee within a trucking organization for removing inefficiencies that eat up a drivers time. Working longer and harder is not the answer. Incentive programs should lead to a driver having to spend less time accomplishing more through time savings that are made in areas beyond the drivers control or sphere of influence. Specifically, load planning and dock retention times. This then allows me as a driver to focus on the issues of safety and fuel management (driving!!) as well as free up time for my personal use.

Recognizing that the responsibility for productivity, safety, and profitability spreads far beyond the reach of the driver and is the mark of a good incentive program. Simply plopping a program into place will not resolve all, if any, of the issues at hand. Hard work and a diligent effort is required by all of us. This is a good discussion to have at an opportune time. I hope the panel discussion I mentioned at the opening takes place. I'm already looking forward to it.

Sunday, 10 June 2012

Hot & Hazy

It's hot and hazy up here in Hearst. The Weather Network is telling me that it feels like 32°C with the humidity. Feels like a hell of a lot more than that sitting in my black truck. The wind has picked up as the temperature has increased. Swirling eddies of dust blow across the now empty parking lot here at the Husky truck stop. As you can see there is not much of a view. I'm waiting for my switch, unable to sleep anymore in the light of day. I will have fulfilled my time off requirements for the day by the time my switch arrives. In theory that makes me well rested for the 11.5 hour drive back to the south. Of course I know better. The last 4 hours will test my stamina.

I've been giving some thought to the panel discussion on driver incentive programs that I will be participating in this coming Tuesday. I attempt to participate regularly in the monthly meeting of the Central Ontario Chapter of the Fleet Safety Council but it's difficult as a driver to make the time available. Available time is at the core of my position regarding incentive programs.

Time to work, time to sleep, time to play, time to eat, time to prepare food, time to exercise, time to plan, time to put your feet up and relax, time to participate in community, time to be a husband, a dad, a grandad, a friend, a neighbor.

Time is in short supply when a truck driver needs it the most yet is abundant when a driver is least able to make the best use of it. That's the position I find myself in this afternoon. It's not the first time and I'm sure it won't be the last.

I'm kicking myself because I volunteered to do this switch. I'd had a long week last week running home doing multiple pick ups in South Dakota and Iowa, but there was plenty of freight to move and too much time off makes for a light pay packet. That was my reasoning. Seemed pretty rational at the time. But now that I find myself in the position of feeling tired before I start and face the prospect of working through the night and having to sleep when I get home in the daytime, well that totally screws up my time off and plans with family.

So this is a core issue the trucking industry needs to address somehow. Taking the hours of wasted time on the road and making them available for a drivers personal use outside of his or her workplace (truck). Simple? Not at all. But necessary.

We need profit sharing based programs that promote efficiency and communication across the whole industry to start tackling this issue. As long as drivers are left sitting on evenings and weekends absorbing the inefficiencies of the Monday to Friday workweek while still meeting delivery expectations at a personal cost to themselves, the driver shortage will continue to deepen until it reaches crisis proportions. It seems like we're almost there.

I love to drive and love the sense of freedom and independence this work brings to me. But not at any cost.