Friday, 25 January 2013

Tuning Out Isn't Always The Best Solution

This post appears in the September 2012 edition of the Truck News


I have been reading a variety of blog posts this summer regarding citizenship, community, and democracy. Most of these blog posts have been investigating the reasons why fewer and fewer of us participate in the democratic process and the feelings of isolation and lack of influence many of us are feeling these days as a result. It was a blog post titled “The Myth of the Silent Majority” written by Glen Pearson that really got me thinking about the challenges the trucking industry faces and what our responsibilities are as individual drivers to influence positive change. Glen summed up the silent majority this way:

“How can drawing in people to care more about their community possibly be wrong, especially in times of great transition or challenge? And how can the presence of a silent and ambivalent majority possibly stand as a viable excuse for the lack of citizen accountability? The presence of a majority of citizens refusing to face impending struggles on behalf of their own community is hardly a testimony to the vigor of the democratic legacy.”

A week or two before reading Glen's blog I was sat in a line of stalled traffic on highway #17 west of Kenora. The 20 kilometer long line of traffic was a result of a fatality accident that had occurred near the Ontario / Manitoba border. I learned this by turning on my CB radio. But it wasn't long before the trash talk started over the radio at which point I joined what I believe to be the silent majority of drivers and turned my radio off. CB trash talk is all about bigotry, hatred, ignorance, and fear. Those feelings have found fertile ground for some in the changes that are taking place around us.

There isn't any doubt that the trucking industry is in a time of great transition and that we are all facing huge challenges as a result. The shortage of qualified drivers, holding drivers to a higher standard through stricter enforcement, exponential growth of technology, the push to adopt that technology in the cab, pressure to improve productivity, pressure to hold down wages, and the impact all of those things have on our lifestyle add to our feelings of angst.

Much of the bigotry and ignorance that prevails over the CB airwaves revolves around immigrant drivers. It has more to do with a fear of change within the North American trucking culture than with driving skill or knowledge. Leaving your homeland and moving to another country with a vastly different culture and lifestyle is about pursuing a better life for your family and it is something that is incredibly difficult to do. I can speak to this with some limited experience. My family immigrated to Canada from Great Britain 45 years ago. Although I was still a child at the time I can still remember the challenges we faced as a family despite sharing a common language and similar cultural norms. The last thing an immigrant family is looking for is a free ride. My parents saw Canada as a land of opportunity that could provide a better life for their family and it certainly did. But there were no guarantees. Success came through hard work and commitment. These are two qualities I believe all people striving for a new beginning in our country share. I think the silent majority would agree with me on that.

There is much room for improvement in how the rules around safety and compliance are enforced. There will always be debate about the validity of some of those rules and whether they are necessary at all. But the fact is that laws governing conduct and the rules of the road need to be in place. Many of those rules have been put in place more for the benefit of the commercial driver than anyone else. I think it may very well be a silent majority of drivers that prefer they are limited to a 70 hour week.

As a group we drivers often complain about the lack of camaraderie today in comparison to the 'good old days'. That feeling is fueled by negative talk over the radio. Many of us have dealt with this by simply turning our CB off. But is that the right approach? Ignoring that attitude certainly doesn't make it go away but at the same time, I admit, that when you engage with drivers on the radio it usually degenerates into a pointless shouting match. It appears that as individuals there's not much we can do to stop or at least tone down the trash talk. I think we can agree there is a silent majority of professionals out there. But in our silence are we allowing the voice of the minority to dominate? Ignoring it certainly does not seem to be making it go away.




Sometimes A Good Incentive Program Isn't About Money

This post appears in the August edition of the Truck News

Truck NewsI wrote last months column prior to participating in a panel discussion on the topic of driver incentive programs. This months column is the post discussion installment.

The event took place at the June 2012 meeting of the Central Ontario Chapter of the Fleet Safety Council. Driver incentives were presented from the perspective of Owner, General Manager, Safety Manager, Dispatcher, Driver, Fixed Operation Staff (dock, warehouse, shop, administration), and Insurance.

The diversity of ideas that break out when you have a broad cross section of people from across the industry coming together to discuss a topic common to all is fascinating. But what is also apparent is that drivers are under represented in these discussions. I find that at these events I am often the only active driver in the room. That is not a criticism or complaint but an observation that in our industry the people in the best position to offer feedback leading to improved efficiency & productivity are most often not in the room to air their concerns and ideas. We live in a time that has been coined as the 'golden age of communication'. We definitely need to find a way to move the discussions that take place amongst drivers on the CB and in the truck stops to the offices and board rooms of the trucking industry.

The second thing that was apparent to me was the age of the participants. Most of the meetings I attend are dominated by the boomer demographic. It's not just the driver pool that is aging. Fresh faces bring fresh ideas. The youth that carriers are attempting to attract to the industry have developed a different set of social skills from the boomers that currently dominate the trucking industry. Have you noticed how we (boomers) tend to take new technologies like social media and twist it into a form we are comfortable with? The youth of today live their lives openly on the internet with few inhibitions or limits and adapt quickly to the rapid changes that are taking place around them both technically and socially. We boomers with our depth of experience usually feel we have much to offer but often forget we have much to learn. The best drivers, the ones that have decades of incident free driving, will often say that the day you think you have seen it all is the day that you should hang up the keys. We need to apply that principle to the industry as a whole.

Am I starting to sound a little negative? Just a bunch of non driving old fogies sitting around making decisions for people doing a job that they are out of touch with? Sorry about that but the fact is that as I cruise across the highways and byways listening to other drivers that is not an uncommon complaint. But it is a complaint that is unfounded in many ways and stems from the communication divide that has developed over the years between drivers and support staff. Owners and managers truly have the best interests of drivers as their prime concern, those that don't do not remain in business for long, especially in our current economy. That is the third thing that stood out for me in our panel discussion, the quality of incentive programs that are in place out there and the genuine concern for the well being of drivers.

What do some of those incentive programs look like? Programs are as diverse as the companies that make up the trucking industry. Many still focus on safety & fuel bonuses as prime motivators. What some people may find surprising is that the most powerful programs we discussed were not monetary based but focused on wellness (driver health) and recognition. Recognition was identified as the key in every successful incentive program. We all want to be complimented and rewarded for a job well done no matter what our position is. So there is definitely no rocket science behind incentive programs. It's simply about treating people well and recognizing them for their accomplishments and those programs work far better when the primary players participate in the process from start to finish.

Some of the fastest growing programs right now are the health and wellness programs. This is a reflection of our aging demographic. There have been weight loss challenges between different companies to motivate healthier lifestyles. Some companies have brought in third party players to administer healthy lifestyle living programs that will aid drivers in developing new habits for eating, exercising and addressing the psychological issues we face in dealing with these lifestyle issues.

All in all it was heartening to see the energy and time that is spent by owners and managers to care for their driver pool.


Why Profit Sharing May Be The Ultimate Incentive Program For Owners & Drivers

This post appears in the July 2012 edition of the Truck News


A few months ago I was asked by the central Ontario chapter of the Fleet Safety Council if I would like to participate in an upcoming panel discussion about driver incentive programs. I accepted, always eager to offer my two cents from a drivers perspective. As thoughts about this topic percolated in my mind over the months I've had quite some difficulty coming to any type of concrete opinion on what a driver incentive program should look like. The best place to start is to gain some understanding of what is meant when we talk about driver incentive.

If you look up a dictionary definition of the word 'incentive' you will get back something to this effect:a reward offered for increased productivity. Increasing productivity is usually associated with an increase in the volume of work performed (usually accomplished by investing more time in the job), performing the same volume of work at a lower cost (fuel savings, accident free), or meeting a higher standard of performance(improving CSA scores or Carrier Rating). The reward to the driver is most often a financial one.

What I find really interesting is that an increase in productivity requires an investment of additional time by the driver. Yet in recent years changes to Hours of Service legislation (HoS) and use of Electronic On Board Recorders (EOBR's) has tightened control over a drivers time. At the same time most of us are still payed by the mile and by the drop. This system was put into place to encourage productivity also. Run more miles, do more drops, and you get payed more. But that system was put into place when HoS rules were loosely enforced or non existent. So what we have now is the operations side of our business still paying drivers by the mile encouraging them to work as quickly as possible in the name of productivity and incentive programs that are designed to slow us down and work more efficiently & safely. This presents somewhat of a paradox for drivers. It's no wonder that drivers often express the feeling that they are stuck between a rock and a hard place because the expectations of the operations side of the business and the safety & compliance side of the business clash. So as a driver are you going to place your efforts on the operations side that pays you 40 cents a mile every week or on the safety and compliance side that presents you with the potential to earn up to another 2-6 cents per mile each quarter, if you meet the criteria? It's no surprise that many drivers feel it's just not worth the effort. Maybe we're well past the time of looking for a new means of paying drivers for their efforts as well as developing new incentive programs.

What if I'm more interested in earning the same money but doing it in less time allowing me more personal time? Is there an incentive program out there that will do that? Perhaps. Some companies are implementing profit sharing programs. These programs present the opportunity to involve all employees, not just drivers, in the incentive program. They have the potential to foster greater teamwork and break down communication barriers between departments. A profit sharing program fixes the cost of an incentive program as a percentage of net profit for the company so it aids in financial forecasting and planning. But it requires diligent and consistent messaging from all levels of management to front line employees. Everyone has to be working towards the same goal. I've learned over the years as a driver that communication with front line employees is not a strength that this industry possesses. That's not a criticism it's a recognition of the difficulty we all face in developing relationships with one another when we rarely see one another. That lack of social interaction is difficult to overcome in an industry that keeps managers and workers thousands of kilometers apart most of the time. A successful profit sharing program depends on constant interaction between all employees if there is to be a payoff. That payoff has the potential to be no less than a satisfactory set of HoS rules that recognizes the need for flexibility in a drivers daily routine and an end to downloading inefficiencies such as dock delays to the driver.

As an aging driver I find that I am increasingly frustrated by the lack of time I can spend with my family and invest in my own personal well being. Issues of driver health and wellness are coming to the forefront and facing up to this reality is what incentive programs also have to address. It does not seem reasonable to me to ask an aging driver pool to invest even more time in the name of productivity while expecting them to take more time to care for themselves. You just can't have it both ways.

Sometimes Saying NO is The Only Option

This post appears in the June edition of the Truck News


There is no doubt that if you choose driving as a career there will be personal sacrifices you will have to make. Long haul work requires an investment of your time that is necessary to get the job done. Let's face it, I can't drive to Winnipeg and home every week if I'm looking for a job with a 40 hour work week. Common sense dictates that you will never be happy in your work as a professional long haul driver if your mind is constantly craving to be at home or dwelling on the frustrating elements of this work that pop up on a regular basis. There are options of course. You can still drive locally or regionally to reduce or eliminate having to sleep in your workplace. That been said, you don't have to give up all of your personal aspirations and goals on your bucket list just because you drive long haul for a living, nor should you.

You have to be careful in this industry not to allow others to possess total control of your time. A good example of this is the carrier that operates on the basis of maxing out a drivers 70 hour work week. We should always remember, especially if you are new to this industry, that the 70/7 day driving maximum was put in place as a safety standard not an employment standard that employers can force their employees to meet as they see fit. Finding a balance that keeps you fit both mentally and physically while reaping the benefits of the freedom and joy this driving lifestyle can bring you is truly the sole responsibility of the individual driver. There are times when you need to say no to the freight and say yes to some personal time in order to look after yourself. Your employer can benefit from that decision just as much as you will. After all a happy & healthy driver is a productive driver.

This point was driven home to me after working out at my health club the other day. First let me give you a little background. If you visit me in this space with any regularity you know that I stepped on the road to health and fitness a decade ago and it is an important part of my daily life. I put the time I need each day to care for myself at the top of my priority list and it changed my life. But I always struggled in the winter months to maintain my fitness. The cold and snow I encounter on the road to Winnipeg every winter is not conducive to walking or running. So I decided to join a fitness club this past winter to maintain my health. It's a national club with locations in cities I drive through regularly. A perfect solution for the winter months.

I work with a personal trainer at my home club and for the past two sessions we were stepping into the next phase of my training, searching for the perfect resistance on each machine that would see me not quite able to lift the weight on the last couple of repetitions on the last set of exercises for each muscle group. On the squat machine this happened to be 100 lbs of weight. As I was driving to Winnipeg the following day it hit me that I had almost lost 100 lbs of weight off my body since the autumn of 2001. Ten years ago that 100 lbs was a burden that I carried with me everyday. With a family history of heart disease I was a ticking time bomb and it was then that I set a goal of reaching a good state of overall health by age 50. I not only met that goal I surpassed it and continue to reach new highs that ten years ago would have seemed more like fantasy to me than a realistic set of goals. In effect that 100 lb burden I carried on my body has become a level of resistance that is now contributing to my health and well being. What a beautiful example of how taking a little time for yourself can benefit you over the long run. I'll remember this every time the thought “I don't have time” arises in my mind.

So, were the times I've had to say no the the freight in order to have some personal time to fulfill my own personal goals been worth it? You bet they have. Has my employer benefited from these results? Of course they have.

As professional drivers we need to take possession of our time and not allow others to dictate its terms of use. I'm convinced this is the path to a balanced life on the road. Nobody else will do this for us.

Striving For a Better Work-Life Balance

This post appears in the May 2012 edition of the Truck News


Our daughter was married on St. Patrick's Day and she certainly had the luck of the Irish on her side. We enjoyed record breaking temperatures, sunny days and everything came off without a hitch. Our house was filled with joyful merrymaking from morning till night for the better part of a week. It was beautiful, now a memory that will be one of the highlights of my life.

On the last Tuesday of March my day ended at the TA truck stop in Hudson, Wisconsin. It was my fourth day back on the road after the high of my holiday and I felt mentally drained and at an emotional low. The solitude of the trucking life that I enjoy seemed, on this day, more like solitary confinement. I was missing the simple pleasure of a morning coffee with my wife and an afternoon walk with my grandson.The greatest job hazard we face as truck drivers is the free time our mind has to play with as we travel down the road. When our minds latch on to thoughts of family times that we all pass up on on a daily basis, we're in trouble. After squeezing my truck into one of the remaining parking spaces at the Hudson truck stop I found my mind had squeezed itself into a tight space of its own.

Looking for a distraction I grabbed the April edition of the Truck News that was sitting on my passenger seat untouched since I picked it up in Thunder Bay two days before. As always I turned first to the editorial page to get a take on our industry from James and Lou.

James Menzies was was asking if we have seen the end of the trucking tycoon. The fact the industry is moving towards consolidation of ownership by large companies as a result of the financial stresses of the day is something I don't find comforting. I'm reminded of a quote from the Dalai Lama, “We need money to live, but we don't need to live for money”. I'm not aware of any of these big companies today that don't live for money. James noted that so many trucking companies today were built on the same foundation of “one guy with a truck, a vision and a truckload of ambition”. I work for one of those guys and his family. Like me, he doesn't live for money either.

Lou Smyrlis tackled the issue of obesity and driver health asking the question, “Does it make sense to continue ignoring this issue when the answer is so simple?” The topic of health and wellness is close to my heart and I have written much in this space about the great strides I have made improving my own health over the past decade. Lou's commentary reminded me that today was one of my 'run days' and I needed to get off my butt and get out of the truck. A workout always improves my outlook on life and helps to pull me out of the doldrums.

These reflections reminded me that I am blessed with a loving wife and family, I work for a group of people that embody the same family values as myself, I have come to grips with the challenges drivers face when it comes to making healthy lifestyle choices on the road, and my profession provides me with ample money with which to live in comfort and provide for my family. You would think this is a recipe that brings a great deal of ease into my daily life yet I seem to be experiencing increasing amounts of anxiety and frustration each time I head out on the road. After much soul searching I can only attribute this feeling to the lack of balance I face each day.

You only need to look at one of the hot topics facing the trucking industry today to understand what I'm talking about. Many trucking organizations (and drivers) advocate extending available driving time, or to put it another way, allow flexibility in the rules to allow more hours of driving per week. Really? How does extending my work week make it easier for me to spend time with my family? How does extending my work week make it easier for me to care for my own health and well being? How does extending my work week reduce the stress and anxiety in my daily life. The answer, on all counts is, it doesn't.

The beauty of this industry in the past was that it always put people first. As consolidation of ownership moves forward the focus has shifted to the bottom line. As long as we are forced to do more with less the daily frustration and anxiety will continue to build and the issues of the day will remain unresolved. Our personal and work lives are out of balance.

The Many Benefits of Taking Pride in Your Profession

This post appears in the April 2012 edition of the Truck News


I started off the year questioning whether new technology being adapted by the trucking industry can have a positive effect on safety if it increases the amount of stress on a driver. I moved on to the driver shortage and its effect on an aging driver pool. Last month I talked about incentive programs for drivers. The common factor in my columns this year has been the time pressure I feel as a driver and how new technology, heavy workloads, and the actions of others effect it. Add in the time demands of my personal life and it's not surprising that I'm left feeling fatigued and stressed out. So what actions can I take on a daily basis to cope with these time pressures? It's not within my circle of influence to make these time pressures go away but I can find ways to cope with the resulting stress, it's effect on my well being, and have a positive influence on the people that make decisions effecting my time.

The best thing I find that I can do is to take pride in what I do each and everyday. Pride in the sense of the pleasure and satisfaction I take in my profession. Taking pride in my skills and experience is one of the most powerful ways to have a positive influence not only on my own attitude but on the level of respect I receive from my peers, my employer, the general public, and customers. When you earn respect for the level of professionalism, skill, and effort you bring to your work each day the people you deal with place a much higher value on your time as a result. It's a simple and powerful way to increase my influence over others whose decisions or actions have a direct effect on how my days play out.

There are three simple ways I believe you can show off your professionalism as a commercial driver:
  • Show pride in your ride and the company you work for
  • Show pride in your driving skills
  • Show pride in the level of customer service you offer

Showing pride in your ride and speaking in a positive way about the people you work for or the company you represent (that might be yourself) always gets peoples attention in a positive way. This is not a difficult thing to do. Other drivers notice, the company you are signed on with recognizes you as someone with a “positive” attitude as do your customers, and you carry a positive image down the highway in the eyes of the general public and enforcement.

Showing pride in how you drive is the best way to get positive attention from the traveling public. Courtesy is something that is contagious. If pride in driving skill becomes a standard for all drivers within the company you work for pretty soon that big company logo traveling down the road earns a whole new level of respect from all drivers. How you drive determines your safety rating, safety bonuses, and reputation as a professional driver within your own company, again, earning you respect for how you drive. How you drive determines whether the freight gets to the customer in one piece and on time. How you drive is the determining factor in how you are judged by other commercial drivers and all levels of enforcement.

Showing pride in the level of customer service you offer is an area that can have the greatest overall impact on your available time and the value others place on it. Service, after all, is the product that we are actually providing to shippers and receivers. If you do a dedicated run or local work the ability to call on the same businesses repeatedly and deal with the same people week after week is a huge advantage when it comes to using your time efficiently. Stress is reduced when you know where you are going and who you are dealing with. You are able to factor in the knowledge you gain from experience and know when to show up, when not to show up, how to access difficult facilities and so on. There is also a great feeling in getting a pat on the back in the form of a simple and genuine thank you from the people you deal with on a regular basis. That's something I missed when I was doing open board work. If you do open board work your company name will go a long way in getting you looked after when your fellow drivers take the same pride as you do in their daily responsibilities.

So taking pride in what you do may not solve all the day to day problems or eliminate all the obstacles but in the long term it can pay big dividends.

What's Got Me Down? It's a Matter Of Time

This post appears in the March 2012 edition of the Truck News


Last month I closed off my column saying that carriers need to find new and creative ways of attracting and holding on to drivers. Shortly after submitting that column I was asked if I had an interest in participating in a panel discussion regarding driver incentive programs. So I thought I would wade into that topic here while it was still fresh in my mind. It also comes at a time when the Truckload Carriers Association (www.truckload.org) will be recognizing the top fleets to drive for (www.bestfleetstodrivefor.com) as nominated by company drivers and owner operators. Several Canadian companies are in the top 20 group and you can read about them on the web sites above as well as here in the Truck News.

I work for a company that stands shoulder to shoulder with the best in the Canadian trucking industry in the way they care for their drivers and the core values that embody their operations. In fact a new incentive program was put in place January 1 of this year for our drivers. Despite that, I have still been experiencing a feelings of discontent and anxiety over the past several months. Colleagues have commented on the degradation of my outlook of late. A comment from a regular reader stated that although they had enjoyed a recent column they felt it was in a negative tone compared to my usual style. Another comment came from within my dispatch office regarding my negative reaction to a situation that had arisen and the feeling that it was out of character for me to react as I did. Can I identify a single factor within my trucking lifestyle that leads to the daily stress I have been experiencing? Could a driver incentive program reduce my daily stress at the same time as providing me with a financial reward and reduce costs/improve profits for my employer?

Identifying the stressor in my daily life on the road is not difficult. It is time. Time is something I always take for granted but it comes up for me over and over again as the leading cause of tension in my life. The birth of my grandson last year lead to a feeling of deep desire to spend more time with my family. The recognition of my need to obtain regular exercise and rest requires a time commitment each and everyday. My time is my most valuable commodity. When my time is being wasted or taken for granted my immediate emotional response is usually one of anger and frustration leading to the feelings of stress and anxiety. Then the endless hours of driving play their part as my mind locks on to those feelings and replays them over and over building on them and strengthening them. The result is an internal conflict over the time I have available to accommodate my personal life and personal aspirations versus the huge block of time required to fulfill my professional obligations as a driver. I often feel a lack of control over my time because so much of my day is dependent on the actions of others. Specifically operations and dispatch along with the shippers and receivers I deal with.

So I was excited to see that profit sharing programs are on the leading edge of new incentive programs being developed by carriers. Why? Because they have the potential to drive a greater level of cooperation and communication within trucking companies. Too often productivity increases have been equated with a driver doing more within a given time or becoming more efficient with the use of their time. Little attention seems to be payed to the fact that drivers already invest well over 3000 hours a year in their jobs compared to the 2000 hours most full time workers put in. That's before you even consider that a driver also lives in his or her workplace. An incentive program needs to reward every employee within a trucking organization for removing inefficiencies that eat up a drivers time. Working longer and harder is not the answer. Incentive programs should lead to a driver having to spend less time accomplishing more through time savings that are made in areas beyond the drivers control or sphere of influence. Specifically, load planning and dock retention times. This then allows me as a driver to focus on the issues of safety and fuel management (driving!!) as well as free up time for my personal use.

Recognizing that the responsibility for productivity, safety, and profitability spreads far beyond the reach of the driver and is the mark of a good incentive program. Simply plopping a program into place will not resolve all, if any, of the issues at hand. Hard work and a diligent effort is required by all of us. This is a good discussion to have at an opportune time. I hope the panel discussion I mentioned at the opening takes place. I'm already looking forward to it.